Aspiration doesn’t pay the train fare

Money, Milburn and making opportunity less costly in the North East The post Aspiration doesn’t pay the train fare appeared first on Bylines Network.

Aspiration doesn’t pay the train fare

‘Do you know if Travelodge has free Wi-Fi?’

This was the opening line of a telephone conversation I overheard on a train this week. I was travelling from Newcastle to Birmingham. The young woman sitting in front of me was travelling from the North East to the Midlands to attend an assessment centre for a graduate role. She wanted to spend the evening in her hotel room preparing for the following day and was clearly excited about the fact she was down to the final few candidates.

As a conversation then developed between some of the passengers around the table, I couldn’t resist listening carefully. On the very day that the Milburn Review was published, it seemed particularly timely to hear directly from a young person navigating some of the challenges it seeks to address. She spoke about the numerous applications she had submitted and the interviews she had attended. Despite her best efforts, opportunity still seemed some distance away.

What particularly struck me, however, was the price tag attached to this latest opportunity. Between her travel and an overnight stay in a budget hotel, attending the assessment centre was going to cost her around £170. As she explained to us, this represented a significant proportion of the money she needed to get by that month. She had enquired about the possibility of having her expenses reimbursed by the prospective employer. Whilst they had declined her request, they had expressed their hope that this wouldn’t deter her from attending!

How many equally capable young people might have withdrawn from that very same recruitment process for no other reason than their financial circumstances? I wonder whether employers would even be able to recognise this as the reason. It reminds me that you need money to make money.

For too many children and young people, money is a prerequisite not only for accessing opportunity but for knowing it exists in the first place. I wonder if this is fuelling the NEET (Not in Education, Employment or Training) crisis to a far greater extent than many of us have bargained for.

Milburn and money matters

This week, there will rightly be much discussion about the findings and recommendations of Alan Milburn’s much anticipated review, From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation. With nearly one million young people in the UK identified as NEET, there is much to be concerned about and economically speaking, society as a whole feels the impact of this. If you are looking for a detailed exposition of the review and its recommendations, there are plenty of other corners of the internet and tabloids already giving this attention.

I’m choosing to take a specific track in relation to this review and one inspired by my own track record of curiosity. I want to explore the intersection of poverty, inequality and youth unemployment, and consider the extent to which financial hardship might be derailing the ambitions and opportunities of an entire generation. After all, it’s one thing to encourage young people to get on board with the opportunities available to them but it is another to ensure they can afford the ticket in the first place.

I am not for one moment suggesting that the NEET crisis is being driven exclusively by poverty or financial hardship. However, my encounter on the train this week serves as a reminder of just how much inequity is baked into some of the very systems and networks through which young people are expected to access opportunity. There is much to welcome in the review. Milburn et al call for a more joined-up approach to supporting young people and challenge the fragmentation of our public services. The importance of prevention is also reflected across the review findings and recommendations. I’m not sure anybody can counter the need for this, whatever their political persuasion or standpoint.

The review is also explicit in its recognition of the role of poverty and inequality. However, I wonder if policy (and at times practice) sometimes make the mistake of positioning poverty as one of a number of barriers, without sufficiently considering the extent to which poverty compounds and exacerbates many of the other barriers that sit alongside it.

Falling Through the Cracks: How childhood hardship shapes life chances is a research report published by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation and Trussell found. The research is fairly compelling at showing how poverty is a core driver of inequalities surrounding many young people navigating opportunities, work and learning.

(Source: JRF, 2026)

The research published only a few months ago also highlights that:

  • 61% of young people who were NEET at the age of 23 had experienced poverty during childhood.
  • Experiencing persistent childhood poverty more than tripled the likelihood of being NEET in young adulthood.
  • Of those who had experienced persistent poverty and were NEET at 17, 56% remained outside education, employment or training at 23. This compared with 33% of those who had not experienced childhood poverty.

(Source: JRF, 2026)

The report identifies that poverty was not included as a variable in one of the analyses undertaken as part of the interim review by Milburn, despite its relationship with several of the risk factors that were included. I’m pleased to see that in yesterday’s release, Milburn states in paragraoph 22:

Poverty and inequality are at the core of the NEET crisis

When we talk about poor mental health, persistent absence, educational disengagement, lower attainment and social isolation, financial hardship is often positioned as one of many barriers. However, I wonder if policy spaces and practice sometimes underestimate the extent to which poverty is not simply another barrier, but a force that exacerbates many of the others. I often think of money (or the absence of it) as an amplifier. The money we have in our pockets and the financial flexibility within our household budgets can help to turn down the volume on some of the challenges that life gives us. Conversely, financial hardship can crank up the volume and add an uncomfortable amount of bass to difficulties that are already being experienced. I could see this even in the ‘one train ticket’ experience that the young person shared this week on a train to the Midlands.

If you want some further insightful research into this then take a look at the work of Udu et al (2026) in BMJ Public Health. Drawing on longitudinal data from over 8,000 young people in the UK, Udu et al estimated that approximately 53% of instances of being NEET at age 17 could be attributed to persistent childhood poverty and family adversity. Young people who had experienced both persistent poverty and poor parental mental health had five times the odds of being NEET compared with those who had experienced low levels of poverty and adversity.

Again, money is not the only explanation for these issues. But neither is poverty a neatly isolated variable that we can consider independently of them. Poverty doesn’t simply sit alongside other forms of adversity, it can amplify them. Perhaps, in efforts to review and tackle the NEET crisis, there is need to spend as much time addressing the amplifier as we do responding to the noise it produces.

Banking on family

Some of the inequalities facing children and young people are already playing out long before a young person submits their first job application. This is one of the reasons I am encouraged by the focus on early opportunity and access indicated in the review.

My own daughter and the topic of work experience is at the forefront of my mind here too. She’s recently been tasked with arranging her own work experience from school. I don’t blame the school for this, and I’m aware many local schools here in the North East will be taking this approach. But I do have issues with how much it depends on children and young people ‘banking’ on the network, and potential networth, of their household. I’m biased clearly, but I’m impressed with my daughter’s initiative and the fact that she won’t let me put out NE Bylines plea to my network for a graphics/art based studio role for a week that will play to her creative talents. But if you do happen to be reading this and know of such opportunities, I’m listening!

Of course, there is a bigger issue here though. I am frustrated by the irony in expecting young people to have experience of work in order to secure work, whilst overlooking the inequity that exists in their ability to acquire that experience in the first place. Research published in June 2026 by Education and Employers, Work Experience: Past, Present and Future, found that:

  • 81% of young people’s work experience placements were arranged by themselves or their families.
  • 78% of school staff identified family connections as the main reason why some young people benefit more than others.
  • Young people who had the highest levels of engagement with employers before the age of 16 had 80% lower odds of becoming NEET than those with the lowest levels of engagement.

Meanwhile, research published by the Sutton Trust in January 2025 found that:

  • Only one in ten internships were secured through an open advertisement.
  • 40% of unpaid interns relied on financial support from their parents.
  • 39% were able to live with family or friends without paying for accommodation.
  • The gap in internship participation between graduates from working-class and middle-class backgrounds had widened from 12 to 20 percentage points since 2018.

The role of place, especially here in the North East, should not be overlooked either. The work of The Sutton Trust is useful in illustrating how much geography and local industries play, or do not play, into the role of making opportunity accessible. I’ve covered these topics before in NE Bylines.

When one considers work experience as just one component part of these issues, it seems that both the bank of Mum and Dad and their proverbial address book can be incredibly useful assets when navigating the world of work. I don’t begrudge parents and carers making use of their financial resources or professional networks to support their children. But I am curious about the extent to which we have designed systems that are so disproportionately reliant on families having access to these things. Who introduced you to a prospective employer and who helps you navigate the nuances of a certain sector are advantages that rarely show up on a CV.

In paragraph 434 of the recent review, Milburn makes the following assertion:

Access to work experience cannot continue to depend on parental networks.

I wholeheartedly agree, but nor should it depend on parental net worth or network. Even when we remove the barriers to securing a placement, we need to understand and address the cost of participating in it. The daily commute, the lunches, the appropriate clothing or even the loss of earnings from a part-time job that a young person might be reliant upon. As we look to expand the work experience entitlement for young people in England, I hope we give sufficient attention to these issues. Otherwise, we risk democratising the entitlement to opportunity on paper whilst doing very little to democratise access to it in practice.

Aspiration doesn’t pay the train fare

train ticket
Photo by Jonathan Borba on Unsplash

If we are to respond meaningfully to the issues identified in this latest review, I think we need to become increasingly curious about three things. I think these apply to anybody working in or alongside education sectors and industry.

  • What are the financial and structural barriers preventing children and young people from accessing opportunities in and beyond the North East?
  • What experiences and encounters are we engineering for children from the earliest stages of their educational journey here in the North East?
  • How are schools, communities, employers and other civic institutions working together to ensure that local economic prosperity translates into opportunity for local people?

Schools have an important role to play in this endeavour, but as I regularly say educational inequality cannot be tackled by education alone. The provision we make available in classrooms on the back of this review is just one component part of a much more complex problem for society here. Nor can or should we expect a new work-readiness measure, another accountability framework or a renewed focus on attainment to compensate for all of the structural inequalities that exist beyond the school gates.

I hope the young person I met on the train gets the job she was travelling to interview for. She certainly wasn’t lacking in aspiration. Nor was she lacking in motivation, commitment or a willingness to work. Her efforts to identify and secure employment are clearly costing her time and money, neither of which she had in endless supply. For all the conversations and reviews we have about making young people ready for the world of work, perhaps we also need to ask some more challenging questions about how ready the world of work is for our young people.

There will undoubtedly be much discussion in the coming months about how much the NEET crisis is costing us as a country and even as a region. Perhaps we should spend a little more time considering what opportunity itself is costing our children and young people. In all of this, I hope we are able to see who cannot afford it.

We cannot afford to overlook this and each of us has a role to play in tackling it.

Become a Friend Free to read, funded by readers. No owner, no ads, no paywall.Join now

The post Aspiration doesn’t pay the train fare appeared first on Bylines Network.