Air pollution shows why NCR’s regional governance approach is flawed
The boundaries of the National Capital Region keep expanding, ostensibly for better management. But that has done little to solve pressing problems.

Planning for a city is difficult enough. Planning for a region is harder. Planning a region whose boundaries keep changing is perhaps the ultimate test of a planner’s optimism.
In 1985, when Delhi’s growth was already spilling beyond its administrative boundaries, the concept of the National Capital Region gained ground with the passage of the NCR Planning Board Act. The original region covered about 30,000 sq km. In addition to the Union territory of Delhi, it also included districts in Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan.
Then the map began to grow. The NCR now stretches over 55,000 sq km and the authorities are already discussing whether the boundaries should be redrawn again.
The NCR was conceived largely in response to Delhi’s physical and economic expansion. However, cities never expand neatly. People commute across boundaries. Jobs attract workers from elsewhere. Housing, industry, and commerce spread along corridors rather than within administrative units.
But there is another problem with the map. The elements that most urgently need regional planning do not recognise it.
Air pollution spans far beyond administrative and regional borders. Drainage, catchment areas, wetlands, forests and the Aravallis have no administrative boundaries. The Yamuna certainly has no interest in which government is responsible for which stretch of it.
The NCR, therefore, has...