Leah Harmony argues that Dave Chappelle’s Madison Square Garden remarks were not a joke but a mirror held up to the right’s double standards on race, violence and “cancel culture.” The real issue, she writes, is the racism too many people refuse to name.
The post Chappelle didn’t tell a joke about Charley Kirk appeared first on San Francisco Bay View.
Dave Chappelle feels better now that Charley Kirk is dead. He told a Madison Square Garden audience, “[Charley Kirk] is looking up at us laughing so hard he can’t breathe.” Then the red world went crazy. The “joke” wasn’t original. It was said by comedian Tony Hench-whatever-his-name-is about George Floyd, instead of Charley Kirk, at The Roast of Kevin Hart on Netflix earlier this year. The same crew defended it like it was fair, true and damn-near biblical.
That wasn’t the worst of the Netflix jokes either. There were slavery jokes. Monkey jokes. Aunt Jemima jokes. There were Baba Duke comparisons. There were lynching jokes. Most of which hit below the belt of Black people worldwide. They justified community violence and police terrorism openly. They recklessly cemented stereotypes that quantifiably cause job discrimination, housing market isolation, financial disparities and community disinvestment. They were not single-target jokes, even though they were defended as Kevin Hart-specific.
Whether on purpose or because of unchecked entitlement and ignorance, they cast a wide net far beyond the political agitators of a cult, or whatever these Charley Kirk, Donald Trump reality-denying maniacs belong to. You know the ones to whom hypocrisies do not apply. These are patriots who complain about America like their life depends on it, but condemn complaints about America as unpatriotic. After all, they are the ones tasked with making America great AGAIN.
So unbalanced, inequitable, unfair as always, the political right is calling Chappelle’s show a “celebration of political violence.” An invocation and acceptance, if you will. They are saying he’s “racist,” “cruel” and “evil.” The loudest whiners against cancel culture are demanding he be “canceled.” Some are calling for his arrest; others even think he should be executed. In short, they’re big mad over there.
“The truth will set you free, but it will piss you off first.” – Gloria Steinem
Dave Chappelle is a stand-up comedian. He is not running for election. He does not have political opponents. Frankly, he’s just a dude. He is funny. He is profound. People enjoy listening to him. Dave does not need to be “canceled.” He canceled his own self to the tune of $50 million years ago. Because of this, he does not cater to the left or right. Because of this, he has been riding the freedom train and able to speak whatever truth he wants, where he wants, and cash in on however much he wants.
“They would rather make a God of a liar than admit they’ve been kneeling before an ordinary man.” – author unknown
Charley Kirk was an ordinary man. He was wrong about many things. He lied to millions of people about statistics, race realities, immigration and politics. Through his public rhetoric, he energized a large group of white “conservative” youth who, in turn, were also wrong because they were lied to and under-educated about the truth of America. They believed they were the people Charley Kirk said they were, without asking why.
So perhaps the reason Dave feels “better” is that Charley Kirk’s voice threatened to send America backward in time. The speeches he gave were used to delete progress made against discrimination by justifying such a thing. Perhaps, to Chappelle, the death of Charley Kirk means the death of those tactics.
But it’s more likely Chappelle was conducting a social experiment.
Madison Square Garden is a coveted venue, a platform unlike any other in America, and Dave did not waste the opportunity. While the political right justifies their own inconsistencies by saying they could understand if the joke had been funny, they are failing to see that no joke was told. They themselves are data for a well-thought-out social experiment on the political right.
Chappelle has done the same to the political left to point out the unbalanced protection and manufactured ascension of the LGBTQ community. By holding the repercussions of minor indiscretions against the unresolved violence and conditions of Black America, most had to acquiesce. He sacrificed amusing the masses. He wasn’t telling a joke. He was again turning the mirror around on America’s fake ass.
“You ever ask why it was easier for Bruce Jenner to change his gender than it was for Cassius Clay to change his name?”—Dave Chappelle, The closer (2021)
Like a script, the political right is freaking out, stuttering nonsense, ignoring blatant double standards, disregarding reality and writing their own outrage manifestos. I’m sure Dave bet on this. But I do not think he is a bad person. I believe he hoped people would see their own hypocrisies and grow from there. That is not likely to come from a group who celebrates George Floyd’s death-day every year by creating intricate campaigns congratulating him on his sobriety, i.e., “congratulations _____ years clean today!” Hopefully he was amused by it all, which is a fair trade-off for failing to change the world.
Ironically, the largest critics of “cancel culture” made it their first order of business to immediately target Chappelle’s sponsors and deals, demanding they cancel their contracts with him. This is, as Dave put it, akin to killing a man.
“Never get between somebody and their paper. Taking a man’s livelihood away from him is akin to killing him.” – Dave Chappelle, Unforgiven (2020)
This country will take away a man’s ability to feed his family, go up a mountain, climb a tree, swim a marathon and drive around the world in a traffic jam, twice, all the while defending the honor of a mediocre man, to avoid the pink elephant in the room: RACISM.
If they are upset because Dave Chappelle is cruel, violent and racist, where was this same energy when Dave Chappelle called Candice Owens a “stank bitch”? Crickets. The difference between George Floyd’s death and Charley Kirk’s death is that Kirk is white and therefore Kirk is a hero to MAGA. George Floyd was not a hero to Black people. He was made a hero by political opportunists. He was simply the newest victim to prove we must still fight against police terrorism.
MAGA missing the point over and over again has become the norm. They have justified the deaths of Cyrus Carmac-Belton because he ALSO had a gun, 1-year-old Kohen Wiley because his mother was with someone who could have been stealing from Walmart. They scoff at the notion that Nolan Wells was murdered because they believe racism is over, and they deny that Karmelo Anthony had a right to defend himself because he was sitting under the other team’s tent. The man they think Floyd was supposedly justifies his death and makes it totally fine to joke about it.
The same can’t be true for the way someone feels about Charley Kirk because Charley Kirk is white. In fact, had George Floyd been white, they would not even have had a reason to look into his drug habits or past indiscretions.
Calling Dave Chappelle racist is simply an excuse to support their double standard. They are correct only in that the two comedians telling the same joke is not the same thing. They hit different because Black people cannot be racist. Racism is attached to power. Power is tied to money. Racism made Shilo Hendrix a millionaire for calling a 5-year-old Black boy a nigger. This month, the actions of the white students who mimicked monkeys at the door of Black students were again justified. The white student who refused to apologize is on her way to becoming a millionaire herself.
White people in this country hold the majority of CEO positions and bank ownership. They own the tech and social media platforms, law enforcement jobs and the presidency. If a white person is racist, then endorsements, sponsors and customers go away. White flight happens and homes lose value when a white person is racist. When a white person is racist, legal protections are removed. If a white person teaches racism, a new generation of racists are positioned to draw red lines, erase history, and arm ICE agents. If they would simply call it what it is, we would get a lot further. For then we could finally begin to address it.
And I believe that’s all Dave was attempting to do.
Leah Harmony is a journalist and Manager of Production at the San Francisco Bay View. She can be reached at leah@sfbayview.com