The Love Island USA Ladies Are Performing For Men Who Don’t Deserve Them — & It’s Hard To Watch
I’ve been cringing at Love Island USA all season long. And it’s not just because of the excessive make outs, disgusting fluid-filled challenges or Kenzie’s splits. With any dating reality show, there’s a level of performance that’s unnatural to what people may do in their everyday lives. It becomes a pressure cooker. One of the most apparent ways that’s shown up consistently in this season of the Peacock reality series is with many of the women on the cast and the ways they are engaging in performative hyperfemininity, or exaggerating behaviors of gender roles stereotypically associated with women. That, unfortunately, is in response to how red pill levels of misogyny have crept into the villa. From the women in the villa isolating Sol to the Casa Amor bombshells asking the men if there’s anything they can improve on, it’s been a hard watch. Yes, it is a dating show, but these women have disempowered themselves and centered men who will never hesitate to put themselves first. An early conversation between Melanie and Beatriz, who was dumped from the island, set the tone for what viewers would witness over the next few weeks. The two sat down to discuss a disagreement they had the night prior. It’s less important who was right or wrong in this situation and more concerning where their kumbaya moment landed. “Do you know how jealous I am that I’m not, like, really athletic?” Melanie told the paralympic medalist. “I look at you and I’m like you could have so much fun with boys.” Bea told Melanie that that doesn’t work in her favor because men tend to see her as “one of them.” She said, “I feel like I need to play into this very feminine role to be here when it’s like I don’t fit into that until a man makes me feel soft.” Though there is truth in their statements in regards to how many men typically approach dating, their conversation was disappointing. Many viewers applauded the honesty of this shared moment. And though it may have been wrapped in tenderness, all I could see was two bold women sharing their desire to shrink who they naturally are to appeal to men. That has been a treacherous theme that has made watching this season more uncomfortable to watch than previous ones. In recent years, dating discourse has positioned patriarchal relationship standards under the guise of woman empowerment. Modern-day red pill discourse encourages women to choose “alpha men” to submit to and assess societal status by using “high value man/woman” labels. This 1950s ideology is predatory and ends up putting young women in positions in which their voices — and livelihoods — are compromised or ignored completely. From an uptick in trad wife social media content to young women mistaking living a soft life for relinquishing authority over their lives, we’ve regressed. That’s dangerous when coupled with the manosphere rhetoric that aims to pedestal men’s value over women’s. On Love Island USA, we’re watching some of the psychological impact that stems from that play out through these relationships. Even in this backswing, there are levels to how hyperfemininity is presented and perceived. Because Kenzie is a blonde-haired, blue-eyed bubbly white woman, she was able to throw a fit and express her disdain about feeling undesired in a way that Aniya and Trinity, dark-skinned women, are not able to without opening themselves up to unfair critiques and the “angry Black woman” stereotype. It’s clear that in the villa, the dark-skinned Black women are held to a different standard. In fact, Aniya and Trinity’s relationships are the only two fellow islander Zach attempts to sabotage by telling their partners that either they aren’t that into them (Trinity) or they aren’t enough for who they’re with (Aniya). It’s hard not to notice, especially in Trinity’s case, the bias in how Zach perceives them. At the same time, Kenzie has repeatedly mentioned wanting to be the prey to a man’s predator and repeatedly objectified herself in a manner that feels like she studied a 2000s era article titled “How to Make Yourself Irresistible to Men.” So much so that she pressured Corbin to break an intimacy boundary he set while coupled up with Melanie. All I could see was two bold women sharing their desire to shrink…to appeal to men. That has been a treacherous theme that has made watching this season more uncomfortable to watch than previous ones. taryn finley We’re also culpable as viewers. Because of Bea’s athleticism and disposition, audiences assumed that she was queer — and maintained their view even after she corrected rumors about her sexuality on Love Island: After Sun. And Melanie can’t just be Melanie in the villa without unfair online discourse. Her experience and ultimate crash out over her partner, Sincere, ends up getting diagnosed by commenters on social media as a result of her previously being plus size, something Melanie shared on the show. On top of all of that, there’s no room for Blac
Black News 
I’ve been cringing at Love Island USA all season long. And it’s not just because of the excessive make outs, disgusting fluid-filled challenges or Kenzie’s splits.
With any dating reality show, there’s a level of performance that’s unnatural to what people may do in their everyday lives. It becomes a pressure cooker. One of the most apparent ways that’s shown up consistently in this season of the Peacock reality series is with many of the women on the cast and the ways they are engaging in performative hyperfemininity, or exaggerating behaviors of gender roles stereotypically associated with women. That, unfortunately, is in response to how red pill levels of misogyny have crept into the villa. From the women in the villa isolating Sol to the Casa Amor bombshells asking the men if there’s anything they can improve on, it’s been a hard watch. Yes, it is a dating show, but these women have disempowered themselves and centered men who will never hesitate to put themselves first.
An early conversation between Melanie and Beatriz, who was dumped from the island, set the tone for what viewers would witness over the next few weeks. The two sat down to discuss a disagreement they had the night prior. It’s less important who was right or wrong in this situation and more concerning where their kumbaya moment landed.
“Do you know how jealous I am that I’m not, like, really athletic?” Melanie told the paralympic medalist. “I look at you and I’m like you could have so much fun with boys.”
Bea told Melanie that that doesn’t work in her favor because men tend to see her as “one of them.” She said, “I feel like I need to play into this very feminine role to be here when it’s like I don’t fit into that until a man makes me feel soft.”
Though there is truth in their statements in regards to how many men typically approach dating, their conversation was disappointing. Many viewers applauded the honesty of this shared moment. And though it may have been wrapped in tenderness, all I could see was two bold women sharing their desire to shrink who they naturally are to appeal to men. That has been a treacherous theme that has made watching this season more uncomfortable to watch than previous ones.
In recent years, dating discourse has positioned patriarchal relationship standards under the guise of woman empowerment. Modern-day red pill discourse encourages women to choose “alpha men” to submit to and assess societal status by using “high value man/woman” labels. This 1950s ideology is predatory and ends up putting young women in positions in which their voices — and livelihoods — are compromised or ignored completely. From an uptick in trad wife social media content to young women mistaking living a soft life for relinquishing authority over their lives, we’ve regressed. That’s dangerous when coupled with the manosphere rhetoric that aims to pedestal men’s value over women’s. On Love Island USA, we’re watching some of the psychological impact that stems from that play out through these relationships.
Even in this backswing, there are levels to how hyperfemininity is presented and perceived. Because Kenzie is a blonde-haired, blue-eyed bubbly white woman, she was able to throw a fit and express her disdain about feeling undesired in a way that Aniya and Trinity, dark-skinned women, are not able to without opening themselves up to unfair critiques and the “angry Black woman” stereotype. It’s clear that in the villa, the dark-skinned Black women are held to a different standard. In fact, Aniya and Trinity’s relationships are the only two fellow islander Zach attempts to sabotage by telling their partners that either they aren’t that into them (Trinity) or they aren’t enough for who they’re with (Aniya). It’s hard not to notice, especially in Trinity’s case, the bias in how Zach perceives them.
At the same time, Kenzie has repeatedly mentioned wanting to be the prey to a man’s predator and repeatedly objectified herself in a manner that feels like she studied a 2000s era article titled “How to Make Yourself Irresistible to Men.” So much so that she pressured Corbin to break an intimacy boundary he set while coupled up with Melanie.
All I could see was two bold women sharing their desire to shrink…to appeal to men. That has been a treacherous theme that has made watching this season more uncomfortable to watch than previous ones.
taryn finley
We’re also culpable as viewers. Because of Bea’s athleticism and disposition, audiences assumed that she was queer — and maintained their view even after she corrected rumors about her sexuality on Love Island: After Sun. And Melanie can’t just be Melanie in the villa without unfair online discourse. Her experience and ultimate crash out over her partner, Sincere, ends up getting diagnosed by commenters on social media as a result of her previously being plus size, something Melanie shared on the show. On top of all of that, there’s no room for Black women’s hair to be imperfect on this show. The Black women are constantly being criticized for how they style their hair with sleuths obsessing over whether their leave-out is visible.
Meanwhile, the men are having their way all season. And in several cases leaning into those regressive gender politics that come straight from manosphere podcasts (ex: Corbin and KC feeling entitled to physical intimacy). These 20-something-year-old women have been turning grey over men in this gamified dating experiment by shrinking themselves, ignoring bright red flags and folding to men who are belittling them. And if there’s more to the story than what we’ve been shown then shame on production for not airing it.
It will always be more entertaining to witness women having fun and advocating for themselves, even if it does get messy. With the exception of Bea’s realness and Sol cussing out Sincere, Trinity’s quips and outspokenness feel like the closest we’ve gotten to that authenticity from the main cast. The three-week stretch of watching these women stick beside the men who have lied to and disrespected them has been painful to watch.
There is hope, however. We’re past the initial shock of Casa Amor and the women witnessing just how much their partners are exploring their options in 4K.
Zach, Bryce, Corbin, KC, Sincere and Caleb aren’t worth performing for. And the quicker the Love Island USA ladies realize that and stop sabotaging their experience, the better this show will get for both them and us. Let’s turn this ship around, ladies!
Want more? Sign up for our newsletter to get the best of Refinery29 Entertainment straight to your inbox.
Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?
Watch Parties Are Back, Thanks To Love Island USA
